Syd Goldfield

It may come as a surprise to the people who read this careless little blog that it takes some planning to file every day, something I do only when I have a new book coming out.

I can’t remember what I intended to write for today, however. Whatever plan I had, it was out the window when I received some bad news: Syd Goldfield died yesterday. Hardcore regulars here know his wife June from the comments section and I think Syd even slipped in here once or twice.

I met Syd soon after I began publishing and he mentioned that he had a admirable goal: He wanted to read 10,000 books in his lifetime. Eventually, I decided to write about his quest.

One of my all-time favorite pieces of journalism is Roger Angell’s “Three for the Tigers,” a rare piece that focuses on fans. Who, if you think about it, are the engine that drives sports. But pieces about books also tend to be all about the writer’s side of thing, with the occasional exception of phenomena such as “Harry Potter” or the “Twilight” series. I’ve always been a big believer that there should be more stories about reading and readers.

And, I guess I can confess now: Last year, I even sent an e-mail to Motoko Rich, who covers publishing for the New York Times, suggesting she write about Syd, because I had calculated he should be close to his goal. She wrote back a very nice note, saying she was swamped at the time.

At any rate, in Syd’s memory, here’s the piece I wrote about him. Once you’re done, come to the comments section if you so choose, and try to figure out how many books you might read in your lifetime. Even if I give myself a somewhat generous 100 books a year over 70 years or reading — well, I come up way short of 10,000, don’t I?

(An inevitable question: Did Syd make it to 10,000? I think so. June dropped me a note, let me know he was close. That’s why, come to think of it, I wrote Rich and suggested him as a story.)

(c) Baltimore Sun, 1999

He was 14, the new kid in town. His father, frustrated when he couldn’t enlist in World War II, had moved the family from Atlantic City to New Haven, Conn., to work in a factory. Sydney Goldfield, all of 105 pounds, was a freshman in a high school where he knew no one.

Then he met Perry Mason.

The family’s landlady had a collection of pulp paperbacks, rows and rows of murder mysteries. She told Syd he was old enough to read them, and he plunged in, starting with the prolific Erle Stanley Gardner. He went through the first book like a hot knife through butter.

Then he opened a blue cloth binder and lettered carefully in green ink: “#1) The Case of the Sulky Girl.” Within days, he had added #2 “(The Case of the Counterfeit Eye”), then #3 (“Mr. Pinkerton Finds a Body”) and on and on. By year’s end, he was writing “#3) Lost Horizon.”

The ink would change, from green to blue to purple — an experimental stage in his late teens, when he was in the 400s — and back to blue. The looseleaf pages would need reinforcement over time. He would refine his coding system, so that series characters were noted in red alongside the titles. He would start recording the author’s names.

But the handwriting remained remarkably unchanged, even as the notebook traveled from Connecticut to Puerto Rico to Indiana to Pennsylvania to Baltimore. It followed Goldfield from the Air Force to college to factory jobs with RCA to Fort Holabird and, finally, to the Social Security Administration, where Goldfield worked until his retirement five years ago.

And then one day — it was May 1994, according to the notebook — Goldfield wrote down #8,300) “Blood Type,” Stephen Greenleaf. He was 65, he had been keeping his list for more than 50 years, and he suddenly realized: If I keep reading at this rate, I could read 10,000 books before I die.

As Cal Ripken Jr. would be the first to tell you, a streak begins as a routine that someone notes for the record.

# # #

There are two reactions when people hear about Goldfield’s march toward 10,000 books. The first — and the only one Goldfield says he ever hears — is “wow.”

But behind his back, people exhibit a kind of competitive envy. They begin toting up in their heads how many books they have read, only to realize that 10,000 books do not come easily, even to the most prodigious reader.

Here’s some context. Each Bibelot store, on average, stocks 90,000- 100,000 individual titles; Goldfield is trying to read 10 percent of the stock. The Duke of Windsor’s personal library comprised an estimated 3,000 titles when it was auctioned in 1998. Goldfield passed that mark in 1968 (“Seven Steps East,” author’s name not listed).

Larissa McFarquhar, writing in the online magazine Slate in 1997, cited a 1992 survey that found the average American adult reads 11.2 books a year; Goldfield reads almost that many books in six weeks, although he has been slowing down since he retired.

More context. The average person reads 250 words per minute; the average novel is 100,000 words. At the normal pace, it takes six hours and 40 minutes to read a book.

Willette Heising, a professional list-maker whose “Detecting Women/Men” guides to series mystery fiction help readers like Goldfield keep their own lists straight, estimates she has read 1,100 novels since 1992. At that rate, she, too, could read 10,000 books — by the middle of the next millennium.

You might think professional readers, acquisition editors at large publishing houses, read 10,000 books in a lifetime. Think again. Robert Weil, an executive editor at W.W. Norton, never has time to read; he’s too busy line- editing.

“I’m in awe of them; I envy them,” Weil says of those amateur readers who have the time and inclination to read. “I wish they’d genetically clone them.”

Weil knows people with libraries of 10,000 books, 20,000 books and, in one case, an estimated 50,000 books. Goldfield owns relatively few books, but no book goes unread in his household. Well, except two: Dorothy Allison’s “Cave- dweller” and “The Corner: A Year in the Life of an Inner-City Neighborhood,” by David Simon and Edward Burns. “Too depressing,” Goldfield says.

A spokeswoman for the Guinness Book of World Records says the company keeps records on publishing, such as the longest poem (the Kirghiz folk epic “Manas,” 500,000 lines) and the largest library (the U.S. Library of Congress). But a reading record would be impossible to verify, although Guinness has received many inquiries.

That’s OK, Goldfield says. He’s not doing it for anyone but himself.

# # #

“He’s just a listmaker and a thinker,” June Goldfield says of her husband of 30 years. “Everything is lists with him. I’m always saying, you need lists of your lists.”

He presented her with a list on their second date: Six things they would need when they married. This list didn’t survive, and they can’t remember every item, but it included a television, a refrigerator, a washing machine and a bedroom set.

He was a widower, fairly new to Baltimore, and Mrs. Goldfield recalls he drove up for a party at her aunt’s house in a little yellow Mustang. When they married in 1969, they moved into the Pikesville split-level where they live to this day. The upstairs, neat as a pin, is her domain. Goldfield and his various collections – - books, records, 45s, autographs — have taken over the downstairs.

He has begun to organize his autograph collection on a computer, but for his list of books, he still uses paper. There is the master list, in the blue binder. There is the monthly list, which he carries with him. There is another list of series books, so he won’t get confused about which ones he has read. He also keeps a detailed diary, which comes in handy. Recently, he had a dispute with George magazine over a bill. All he had to do was consult his daily diary; he knew he had paid it.

He dropp
ed George as a result of that disagreement, but he doesn’t lack for periodicals. June tries to count them up in her head. “The New Yorker. Time. The Jewish Times. The Owings Mills Times. City Paper — he picks that up while he’s out. The East Baltimore Guide, which I bring home from work.”

When there were three newspapers in Baltimore, Goldfield subscribed to them all.

“I just really like to read,” he says. He was 68 before he needed bifocals.

His list of books has few overlaps with the kind of lists that purport to include the most important books of the century, or in the history of the English language. His favorite authors are Ellery Queen, John Dickson Carr and his very first writer, Erle Stanley Gardner. “Sometimes, I get a yen for autobiographies,” he says, but oh, how they slow him down.

Strangely, retirement has slowed his reading. He’s lucky if he reads seven to eight books a month these days. He keeps one book in the bathroom, one in the bedroom. The last book he read was “Reckless Endangerment” by Robert K. Tanenbaum, which is somewhere in the 9,300 range — he won’t know the exact number until he transfers his November reads from the monthly list to the definitive one. He thinks Sara Paretsky’s “Hard Time,” inscribed by the author, will be next. (“Go Red Sox,” Paretsky wrote, after Goldfield confided that he hated the New York Yankees.)

His last good spell of reading came in September, when he was on bed rest after surgery. The list shows he read 16 books that month — he hasn’t seen numbers like that since he was 14 and working his way through his landlady’s paperback mysteries.

But he has to stay healthy to reach 10,000. At his current pace, he calculates he needs another five or six years to hit the magic mark. He’s beginning to think it should be a pretty special book. A mystery, because he loves mysteries. But he doesn’t want to get ahead of himself.

The fact is, the mark is largely symbolic, not unlike the millennium itself. There are books he read before he began keeping the list. Some books — “Lost Horizon,” for example — he read twice by mistake, so he counted them twice. And “The Complete Works of Sherlock Holmes,” #10, could have been five entries.

Mrs. Goldfield said to him the other night: “I hope you hit 10,000 and beyond.” He’s not taking anything for granted, but he knows if he hits 10,000, the next day he’ll pick up 10,001.

“Maybe it sounds kind of egotistical,” he says, “but I’m doing this for myself. I just like to read.”

Share

18 thoughts on “Syd Goldfield

  1. What a wonderful story and amazing man! I’m curious, Laura, how many of your books he read. I remember having to keep a reading list during the summer in grade school, but that was prescribed, not pleasure, reading. A feat like Syd’s is hard to imagine, let alone imitate. I hope some library will buy a book or two in his memory.

  2. Syd was one of my readers, a fact around which I had to tread carefully at the time, as it would have been considered a blatant conflict of interest by some of my bosses. (Those would be the bosses who hated the fact that I was a writer.) But, at the time I wrote, I would have made up no more than three of those books.

    I’ll have to check the records here, but I think June and Syd attempted to attend one of my events last year, but parking was a snarl and they had to retreat.

  3. Hopefully, your current “bosses” do not hate writers. Nice story, Laura.
    I often joke that my job as a sales manager pays me to read books in hotels, airplanes and restaurants (there is nothing worse than eating alone with nothing to read). I generally knock of two or three a week, which, compared to my TV watching wife and friends, is a huge amount.
    But nowhere near Syd’s feat.
    Wow. And he managed to fit in a life around all that reading as well.

  4. Great story, and Goodness gracious! That fellow was a READER!

    I tend to be one of those ‘don’t want the book to end’ slow readers, when I like the book. This makes me value nonfiction, since at least then you have the chance of knowing a true thing or two, in conversation. If you added up my yearly total of books read, it would be in the unimpressively low double digits (not counting Dora the Explorer adventures, etc)

    But my mom used to always read 5-7 books every week, back when the library truck came each Tuesday

  5. My condolences to June Goldfield.

    Syd is my hero. I’ve got a list on excel of my library, but I must admit that I’ve slacked off in the last year. I’m up over 1000, but don’t count what I’ve re-read, which I do a lot.

    I’ll bet my dad is close to 10,000. The man will read anything (even though I despair of his taste at times).

  6. I’m sorry to hear that Syd is gone. And I’m jealous that he had the list he maintained his whole life.

    I lost the list from the time I graduated college until early in the days of our first computer, which was really a toy. I had compiled all the bits of paper into a list, then the computer crashed before I ever printed it out. Shortly after that my first kid interfered with reading for a good while. But I started a list again in June of 94, when I could count books per month instead of books per year on one hand, and since that time I have read 1320 books. So at my recent average of 100 per year, I probably won’t reach half of Syd’s 10,000.

    Of that 1320, twelve are Laura’s books, and I own the others, but generally choose by what I’m in the mood to read. Even when I was an English major, I chose my classes by the reading list.

  7. Speaking of lists, my SO is a list person. When we were dating, he had an index card in his shirt pocket with topics of conversation he wanted to share with me. It cracked me up!

    June Goldfield has my sympathy on her loss. I can’t imagine losing my SO who, BTW, is 71 and has been made redundant by the local school system where he has taught two classes following 30 years in the USN.

  8. My sincere condolences. Syd and I only emailed once (one of the great gifts of this project is being able to make contact “off board”), but I would like to share his response to me (after he learned that I was a resident of Connecticut). He clearly was so proud of his association with Laura and with his amazing love of books. His message from last year:
    * * *
    If you are middle aged, then I am ancient. I was a grad of Hillhouse High in 1946. (New Haven) And UConn in 1953. I have every book by LL.
    I am rapidly (!) approaching 10,000 books read. LL when a reporter for the sun ,interviewed me (my only claim to fame.)

    El Syd
    * * *
    Rest in peace, Syd, and may the library be well-stocked whereever you are now.

  9. Sad news; much sympathy to June. What a wonderful story, and what a terrific goal.

    I kept a running list of my reading for many years, but stopped a few years ago when I started making a living as an editor and proofreader — it’s true, the transition from amateur to professional cut my pleasure reading by more than half. In a good week or a slow week I might still get through four books, but I’m now on a 150-book a year pace, when I used to read closer to 300. I’ll generously estimate my current tally at 3,000, which means I need to live at least another 50 years to make it to 10,000.

  10. The Ed Hoch of reading…I love that.

    Lovely article, Laura–wish I’d gotten to know “El Syd.”

    And, boy, do I agree with you about “Three for the Tigers.” That’s a great comparison as well.

  11. Let’s see if this works:

    <a href=”http://books.google.com/books?id=RAmd_pqSBbUC&pg=PA96&lpg=PA96&dq=Roger+Angell+Three+for+the+Tigers&source=bl&ots=WbdZih1lY2&sig=xqFGuac0Wi_O-hxGn7j-mBl3qb8&hl=en&ei=qDqxSYvlE56Dtwfpx-3DBw&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=2&ct=result
    “>Three for the Tigers</a>

  12. I think I’m probably somewhere around 10,000. I don’t have a complete list. I have kept track at times, using Willetta’s matrials and a computer list. For years, I’ve read around 200 books. But, there were some early years, when it was over a thousand. Like Syd, those weren’t from the best lists of anything. I’m a compulsive reader, if I miss reading the paper, I save it, till I do. After a few days, it’s even quicker to go through, because I know how some stories end up and I can skip them.

    I’m sure that over a thousand of them were read at the feet of Amelia Earhart, a statue of her, actually. It’s in North Hollywood Park, outside the Amelia Earhart branch of the Los Angeles Public Library. She lived nearby, before she disapeared.

    At this point, I think it would probably be a conflict of interest for Laura to write about me. I’ve read way more than three of her books.

    Reading is much more of a pleasure, than a duty. It doesn’t sem teh material of records. Are there records for other things like that, say the most kisses in a lifetime?

  13. Don,

    As a former journalist, I’m now free from worrying about such things. (Although I dutifully listed as the potential conflicts of interest when I composed a recent list for a newspaper.)

    I love what you say about reading as a pleasure, but I think Syd’s list gave him great pleasure as well, He was, after all, a quantifier. I love the detail, which I had forgotten, about how he presented June with a list of things they would need when they marry.

    Just yesterday, I realized that I am one of those people who, when faced with a daunting number of various things to do, requires a list, on paper, with items that I can draw lines through upon completion.

  14. RIP, Syd.

    I have never kept a book list, never even tried. I have no idea how many books I’ve read or reread but I would estimate in the low thousands, no where near Syd or Don.

    OTOH, I’m like Laura in that I when faced with a major task, I do make a list because I love drawing the line through what has been done. Then I feel like I have really accomplished something

  15. 10,000 seems like a great number — achievable, but only with years of dedicated effort.

    I read an average of 150 books per year, which means I’d reach 10,000 in 67 years. (I think I’m actually ahead of the curve, since I used to read more than I do now.)

    So I think that’s probably within reach… unless I keep eating so many double cheeseburgers.

  16. Laura, I just now felt like going to email. Thank you for that wonderful tribute to Syd and thank you to all the readers for your condolences.

    We do own all of Laura’s books, most of which he was able to have autographed. He thought a lot of Laura as a person as well as an author. There is nothing anyone could have said about him that would have pleased him more than to have been the subject of a Memory Project.

Leave a Reply